West Malvern Hall & Village. Book the Hall & Village matters. Publish your event
details and dates here.
The website is in two parts to avoid confusion and too many
buttons! Navigate from one to the other via this ‘Home’ page.
Village Hall: What
goes on and when, availability - the booking calendar is regularly updated. Prices
and a simple booking procedure are here. How to find us. Monthly Hundred Club winners
and other information are in this section too.
Village: This is about West Malvern
- a busy community. This site is dynamic with regular changes to keep up to date
with village events before they happen.
Angie Cantrell, West Malvern’s
correspondent is a regular, weekly, contributor. Her e-mail address and phone number
are on the W Malvern News page. Contact her to be sure you have the publicity you
deserve.
Pictures are better than a thousand words. Don’t be shy, send in yours -
it’ll be good to have a visual focus. Make your views known too about anything local
in these pages. Peter Garners wonderful articles are on the Nature page.
All
of the advert donations go to support the running of the Village Hall. It
is hoped to complete the village section soon.
West Malvern Hall & Village - for West Malvern Hall bookings. Check 100 Club results
- see what goes on. West Malvern Village section is for a variety of local matters
such as news, pictures & gallery, what’s going on, local directory, input for readers,
etc. Also some reading material about West Malvern itself for those interested.
Notices
in Brief: Notices form is on Community page. wm-web@talktalk.net
An
easy way to register your interest in Super-fast Broadband - HERE You can help to
make it happen!
West Malvern Hall and Village
Open Garden at David and Heather’s - Croft Bank, April 16th 2013. More pictures
on Gallery page
Also see ‘What’s on’ page for more West Malvern Open Gardens in July.
All donations to charity.
West Malvern’s Black and White Heritage - a future article.
There is an appeal pending about Planning Application number 12/00952/FUL - 19 Croft
Bank
For information currently available click on the Malvern Hills District Council
Planning Department link and enter the above number
The property in question - 19 Croft Bank
Show || Hide
A personal view
- an open letter
Proposed building
Planning Inspectorate Ref: APP/J1860/A/13/2194382
for 12/00952/FUL
A few years ago neighbours, who lived almost directly opposite to number 23, divided
what was at that time their thatched cottage garden lengthways and applied for planning
permission to build a reasonably sized two storey house in the then houseless second
half.
This was done in an open, friendly and considerate manner. Much consideration
too was given to preserve the general ambience of Croft Bank, ensuring a careful
blending into this AONB. To the best of my knowledge there was not a single complaint,
the garden is a joy and we are all pleased that the neighbours are still here; now
living in the new house. The house has a pitched roof as have all the others in this
area and is set away from the road in a garden big enough for it to fit comfortably.
The contrast with the ill-considered and flawed planning application, 12/00952/FUL
- 19 Croft Bank, could not be more stark. It is quite clear that the idea is to shoehorn
as big a building as possible into a narrow garden regardless of the consequences.
Objections are numerous. Contrary to the agent’s letter of appeal to the Planning
Inspectorate Officer (page 1) the proposed building is incongruous, too large and
plain ugly. Further, it is detrimental to the street scene as well as hiding the
southern side of a most beautiful late 1800’s cottage of local historic value. The
awful damage would be obvious when viewed from about 100 - 150 metres down the road
- before it is built. If built, this tragic mistake would become patently obvious.
For ever.
I put it to the applicants: if they lived in 19 Croft Bank and somebody
else proposed to build what is planned, they would be absolutely horrified and be
the first to complain most vocally. But they don’t. They live in Suffolk.
Questions
for the agent. Why the false and misleading statement (page 2) that I am not a neighbour
to no. 19? Why the misleading statement (page 2) that I am suggesting no. 19 is in
danger of being demolished? But it is in danger. In danger of having its southern,
visually important aspect hidden; of having its aesthetic setting ruined; of being
stuck beside an ugly building that will dominate it. Why furnish the Planning Inspectorate
with a print from the westmalvernhallandvillage.net website’s objection to 12/00165/FUL
- with red lines - instead of the objection to 12/00952/FUL? Hover the pointer over
the icon on the Croft Bank picture to see the proposed building. The difference to
the original is small: the building is still up tight against the no. 19 - 23 boundary.
There
were other anomalies (read glaring mistakes and misleading statement) on the planning
application 12/00165/FUL which were pointed out, ignored, and carried over to application
12/00952/FUL (12/00165/FUL was withdrawn). I will not go into them again here as
they have been well documented, save that our serious concern about the long-established
laurel hedge between no. 19 and 23 has been completely ignored. One can only guess
why. This hedge is a strong feature of the immediate area as it runs between the
two properties from pavement to the very back. If this over-wide construction goes
ahead this hedge will be ruined.
So far then no redeeming features. But wait. It gets
worse. The roof! The planning application 12/00952/FUL shows a flat roof to keep
within the roof-line between nos. 19 and 23. It is most unpopular. Strange then,
is it not, that the appeal document has suddenly sprouted a pitched roof? Two actually.
One version shows the pitched roof as high as the existing cottage. The other above
the cottage height, even though the proposed building is stepped down! Convincing
evidence. The building is too large, viewed from any angle, with flat or pitched
roof. More so if it’s pitched.
This planning application is unsympathetic, too large
and inappropriate for the plot and area. A professional should have known this in
the first place. A professional should have taken the hint with the number of objections
to the first submission. A professional should not have been surprised that an even
greater number of people objected after submitting an almost identical proposal.
They were not impressed with a little tinkering around the edges as it shows a total
lack of regard and consideration for the cottage and for the people of West Malvern;
a hiking and tourist area. The Planning Department did the right thing by refusing
this application. We trust that the Planning Inspectorate throws this out once and
for all without equivocation.
If you have chanced on this and are in general agreement you may wish to support the Planning Department by writing to the Planning Inspectorate.
A final thought - part of a letter from English Heritage: …. it is acknowledged that No. 19 Croft Bank makes a strong contribution to the West Malvern's street scene and has local interest for its association with Lady Howard de Walden …. J Mast
Thatched cottage - close to and opposite no.19